Event box

Why theory matters: New arguments for an old conclusion

Why theory matters: New arguments for an old conclusion Online

Theories are what we accept or reject in the game of science; what we use to explain and predict phenomena, observations, and measurements; and what we compare to evaluate progress and stagnation. Yet, in recent years, the motivation for theory has become uncertain and unclear, particularly in fields that rely heavily on observation or experimentation (e.g., psychology) or that are becoming increasingly data-driven (e.g., neuroscience). Traditional arguments for theory may be rationally convincing but fail to change day-to-day research practices in these fields. A new argument for theory is proposed, starting from an analysis of the so-called ‘replication crisis’ and a model of the interplay between theory development and theory testing in psychology. For empirically-minded researchers in these fields, the value of theory development may lie in restricting the space of possible hypotheses and models to those that have greater a priori plausibility, thus reducing the risks (and costs) of pursuing false or even impossible empirical claims. However, the motivation for theory needs to be rediscovered and reconstructed anew as the context of a particular research field shifts, and traditional arguments should not be invoked uncritically if they are to retain their power to influence beliefs and practices. 

Host: Antonio Schettino
Presenter: Giosuè Baggio (Norwegian University of Science and Technology)


     Giosuè Baggio

Tuesday 15 March 2022
10:00 - 10:30
Time Zone:
Central European Time (change)
This is an online event. Event URL will be sent via registration email.
Registration has closed.

We advise our EMC colleagues who have problems with the registration to email the Campaign Organizers.

This online event will be recorded and made available for future viewing.

The confirmation email may go to your junk mail folder. If you do not see it in your Inbox, check there. The confirmation email will be from Libcal.

All logos of the campaign were created by Josien Dümmer and distributed under CC-BY 4.0 license.

     Back to Open Science Campaign calendar     


Profile photo of in collaboration with
in collaboration with

the University Library and Erasmus Research Services (ERS)

Contact: Campaign Organizers



Opening hours